"Similarly, older women should be reverent in their behavior, not slanderers, not addicted to drink, teaching what is good, (4) so that they may train younger women to love their husbands and children, (5) to be self-controlled, chaste, good homemakers, under the control of their husbands, so that the word of God may not be discredited."Let me back up a moment. A woman for whom I have a great deal of respect once told me that she will never give advice. Despite the fact that she has a large family that includes older children and certainly qualifies as a midlife mom, she will never teach other women and she will never suggest to them a certain way to do something. She said that she would never endeavor to offer someone else mothering or homemaking advice since she's a work in progress and she can't be sure that she's doing it "right." Her oldest children haven't turned out perfectly, so she believes she isn't qualified. Furthermore, she said, she'd never endeavor to write a book. In her judgment, authors of mothering books have imprudent audacity. She volunteered this perspective right around the time my second book was published. I felt like I'd been punched in the gut. For about two years.
Wow. Today's reflection really cuts to the heart about giving and receiving mothering advice. My gut reaction is that I don't worry too much about what I say to others or what they will think. But honestly, that's not true. Sometimes, and with some subjects, I don't say anything, because I don't think I have the "right" to give advice. Indeed, the constant maxim from mothering articles is to "follow your instincts, do it your own way, there is no right or wrong way." And yet, most of these are militantly proclaiming the "right" way to parent, and citing studies to prove what one should or should not do as a parent. And all in an effort to supply what has been lost with the breakdown of society and the lack of support for new mothers from their moms, grandmothers, and other moms in the community.
Yet we are instructed by the Bible, no less, to help other women learn how to be godly wives and mothers. Besides, I believe that many of the things I do are not only right, but very important for the health and well being of my family, and consequently, are "right" for everyone. Shouldn't I want to share these things with others? They don't have to take my advice, but shouldn't I at least offer the wisdom I have received?
After all, I am tremendously grateful for the women, books, and magazines that have helped me in various ways to be learn how to be a good wife and mother. Isn't that why I'm reading and reflecting on these very blog posts!? I guess the lesson for me is to learn how to humbly and helpfully offer advice to other women.
